Created by Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuck (of Glee fame), American Horror Story has undergone many, many changes throughout its staggering thirteen season run. We’ve had it all, from haunted houses and asylums, to a man covering his face in blended Cheetos in order to look like a certain Orange man. But it’s last season – titled Delicate – starring Kim Kardashian and Emma Roberts was panned by audiences and critics, with its finale reaching a very low 3.3 on IMDB, a clear sense of direction needed to occur.
Enter Season 13.
It was all so promising. Everyone was returning: Evan Peters, Sarah Paulson, Kathy Bates, Angela Bassett, and most importantly, Jessica Lange as all her previous characters (she hasn’t appeared on the show since Season 4 – bar a special guest appearance in Season 8). We were finally back to thirteen episodes, after doing so many ten episode seasons that always seemed to rush through to a limp ending. Ryan Murphy was even directing the premiere, his last credit dating back to 2015 with Hotel, which many fans consider the last good season. His focus seemed to have waned from the show since Freak Show. This was the All Stars season. This was the season to end all seasons. American Horror Story: Endgame. And instead, what we got is arguably one of the messiest seasons of television I have had the misfortune of watching.
Aptly titled 13, this latest season focuses is, well, on just how scary the number 13 is. Our main protagonist Ben (played by Ryan Murphyverse regular Joey Pollari) suffers from Triskaidekaphobia – a fear of the number 13. When his number 13 obsessed girlfriend Kira (played by Riverdale alum Madeline Petch) dies in a plane crash along with her twelve friends (see the theme), he begins to work at an ominous high rise apartment complex in New York, looking after a elderly man named Mr. Nas, who may or may not have something more malicious up his sleeve. And yes, you guessed it, it may have something to do with the number 13. Along the way, he meets a collection of returning American Horror Story characters – some long deceased and some mysteriously brought back, including the witches from Season 3’s Coven – and must find out what is truly going on before it is too late.
One might wonder what is so terrible about a seemingly apt topic for American Horror Story. The inherent problem with it is the writing, and the fact that it seems intent on positing that nothing really matters. The dialogue is terrible. Plot threads are discarded without a thought, giving way to John Waters raving on about kinks for three minutes in the 38 minute finale rather than progressing the plot forward, while developments for other characters happen off screen. Lines that have no relevance to the plot are said purely as a callback or because they were funny memes, and characters pop in and out of episodes with no sense of continuity or interest. Everyone gets resurrected willy nilly, and no one really stays dead. It is all well and good to have beautiful cinematography, top notch prosthetics, and a great set, but when the dialogue is just a bunch of sex gags, Jessica Lange repeating “urethra”, and Emma Roberts saying some of the most unspeakable and appalling things I have heard on a major television programme, there is not much that can be done to save the show.
There is some good peppered here and there: the camera work is fresh and vibrant, a mixture of slow zooms, upside down tricks, crashes, fish eyes and a sense of energy pervading the screen. Evan Peters has fun throughout, and the returning Lange heralds a sense of gravitas, even when she is saying utterly ridiculous lines of dialogue. The prosthetics and makeup are top notch as always, layers of gore and bubbling skin impressing with their viscera, and the set design is incredibly detailed.
Nevertheless, none of this can make up for the atrociousness of the finale. At 2.6 out of 10, it deservedly has the lowest rating of a scripted show on IMDB, unspeakably bad until its sudden stop and unearned conclusion. This season as a whole is far too happy with itself, and rather than telling a satisfying story, it is instead just a hodgepodge of random lines and character moments. It’s forgivable because of its production design and Peters’ and Lange’s performances, but overall, this is just a bizarrely bad season of television to round out what was once an excellent show.
American Horror Story is on Disney+ now.




